
On 29 March, an interesting conference on a theme of great importance, such as the breeding stations, was held at the Citadel of the Oasi of Troina to deal more generally with some issues about native breeds of Sicilian horses.
The initial greetings saw briefly intervene the mayor of Troina Ing. Alfio Giachino and the member of the Sicilian Chamber of Deputies Fabio Venezia. Both have guaranteed their personal and institutional interest and commitment in favor of the native Sicilian equine breeds.
Dr. Stefania Marino, from the Italian Chamber of Deputies Agriculture Committee, briefly highlighted new issues related to animal movement and the spread of infectious diseases. She also pointed out that Italy’s livestock sector does not receive enough general attention.
Prof. Giovanni Catone of the University of Messina has reiterated the danger related to the return of infectious diseases almost eradicated, recalling that precisely the breeding station is also a place for breeders’ education in the fight against diseases.
Dr. Michele Bentivegna, Director of the Equestrian Growth Institute of Catania, has indicated the breeding stations as the starting points for breeding, remembering how up to thirty years ago, the Sicilian breeding stations had a distribution with more than 50 units scattered throughout the island. The number of public and private breeding stations today is expected to increase considerably soon. He also announced that the Institute had purchased the first Sicilian Horse stallion to be placed in Ambelia: Trionfo Siculo II°, which belonged to the Morello family. He confirmed that research projects on native breeds, carried out in collaboration with the Sicilian Universities, continue without interruptions, and it is also hoped to soon have in Ambelia the first group of Sicilian Grey donkeys. He concluded by bringing the greetings of the president of ARACS (Regional Association of Sicilian Horse Breeders), who could not attend the conference due to a professional emergency at the last moment.
Particularly striking was the brief intervention by Prof. Francesco Sottile, university professor and scientific director on biodiversity for Slow Food. He stressed the absolute need to break down the barriers between Environmental protection and Agriculture and animal biodiversity protection because they are a unique interconnected ecosystem, especially in Sicily. Hydrogeological disturbances, climate change, severe droughts, state of pastures and forests, and an increase in CO2 are interrelated and affect the natural environment and the agro-zoo technical sector in a univocal framework.
Dr. Luca Marcora, President of ANAREAI, confirmed a growing national interest in initiatives for the conservation of equine breeds with limited spread and, therefore, at risk of extinction and added how vital the breeding stations are in containing and controlling the dangerous consanguinity of subjects.
The moderator, Prof. Santo Caracappa of the Experimental Zoo Technical Institute, then opened the works with the interventions of the different specialists in their fields.

Morphology in comparison: Sanfratellano, Oriental thoroughbred (P.S.O.) and Sicilian.
Prof. Alessandro Zumbo of UNIME, after some historical and documentation references related to the Ragusano, Pantesco and Grey Sicilian donkeys, introduced the three Sicilian horse breeds, remembering how the P.S.O. has its stud book since 1875, coming from the old Royal Stallion Depot, then passed to the Institute of Horse Growth of Catania. The scientific research carried out in 2006, with a genetic and morphological analysis (on 25 different measurements), has classified this noble equine product of excellence as a mesomorph/ dolicomorph horse for the saddle, light carriage with a high predisposition to the sport of endurance.
For the Sanfratellano, he recalled scientific bibliographical references dating back to 1826 regarding the request to safeguard the horse that has its genealogical book since 1995, and its first market exhibition dates back to 1948. The scientific morphological and genetic surveys carried out in the past (out of 25 measurements also in this case) covered 220 subjects, indicating that in recent years there have been on average higher numbers of subjects and, a surprising fact, the profile that characterizes the species has been reduced to only 18% of the subjects. In contrast, as much as 52% have a straight profile. It is a meso dolicomorph or dolicomorph subject suitable for equestrian tourism that today tends to be oriented also to the sporting fields to increase its market possibilities, as the trends of the race numerically on decline.
Regarding the Sicilian horse, the first research project of 2008 aimed at a genetic-morphological survey on 194 subjects of the Indigenous Sicilian, after which it was impossible to obtain recognition of the breed. Subsequently, thanks to the synergies that have united breeders (under the 30-year-long work of ARACS) and various scientific and regional bodies in close collaboration with ANAREAI, it has come to the recognition of February 2024. It is a meso and dolicomorph horse suitable for its versatility for equestrian tourism, work equitation, dressage and the other Olympic equestrian disciplines. He reiterated that Sicily is at the center, not only geographically, of the equine biodiversity of the entire Mediterranean basin.
Ethology of the horse: Sanfratellano, Oriental thoroughbred (P.S.O.) and Sicilian breeds.

Prof. Michele Panzera of UNIME has therefore intervened, starting from considering the question about the millenary selection of the horse: “who started?”. The answer is ” the environment” that sculpts the morphological type, and, therefore, the integrity of the morphological type comes from the integrity of the environment. The different factors of the coastal, hilly and mountainous Sicilian environments, however, have not only sculpted the morphology of the subjects but also and above all what the classical hyppologists have described with an abundance of details, namely their “moral qualities”. That is their temperament, disposition and character. So we must ask ourselves if it is not the case that, in addition to establishing selections for morphological and genetic standards and parameters should not be taken into account in the work of gene improvement also include a selection that specifically concerns these “moral qualities” (which today are quantifiable scientifically) so important in an animal with which man enters into such a close relationship in the various daily uses of today because, as expressed by Guaita in his treaties of the last century, “the standard of living also contributes to shaping the individual’s character qualities”. This is to be taken into greater account considering the living conditions of horses today in the stables of equestrian centers that are man-sized and not horse-sized (and in training methods).
Genetics of the Sicilian horse.

Prof. Salvatore Bordonaro of UNICT explained how it all began in 2003, thanks to a series of meetings and subsequent non-continuous research projects that have included the search for historical documentation of the past, coming from the dozens of breeding stations of the Institute and the Royal Stallion Depot scattered in Sicily, which tell of the presence in the selections of many English thoroughbred, Orientals, Anglo-Orientals but also Lipizzans nuclei, Persanos and other horses (not to mention the genetic influences from 1500 onwards with the horses arrived with the Arab, Norman and Spanish dominations) in the development of Sicilian breeds. That data will be studied with a specific project.
In genetic research, microsatellite markers have been used to study the genetics of the three Sicilian breeds and their mitochondrial DNA, which allows investigating the phylogeny of the races (that is the reconstruction of the stages characterizing the evolution of a systematic group of animals or plants and also the graphical representation of this reconstruction). The link between the Sicilian breeds also shows some particularities, such as that of a Nebrodian mare which had the haplotype B identified in a horse from an archaeological site in Mongolia, as well as the uniqueness of the U haplotype in all the P.S.O. or the specific haplotype that unites all the Pantean donkeys.
He then presented a whole series of color charts that represented all the individuals studied over time, first with a study on the different genetic lines of the Sanfratellano developed over time and then a congruent number of PSO’s and Sicilians that highlight how, in various ways, the three races have interacted with each other over time. With three years to sign off Sicilian horses from which to take samples of blood and DNA, researchers will have a lot of data that, together with those already taken from 2003 and on, will allow to investigate much more deeply on the Sicilian horse and, on the other hand, also on the other two Sicilian races to which it is still linked.
Standard of the Sicilian horse breed.

Dr. Vasini of ANAREAI explained the three-year work that is taking place, after the successful recognition of the breed of the Sicilian in 2024, with the campaigns of selection concerning the Sicilian horses to be able to insert them in the breed’s stud book. This is done through a morphological examination during which a sample of hair and blood is taken from each subject for all the relevant genetic analyses, already introduced by Prof. Bordonaro concerning the past, to be able to carry out a series of tests on many subjects which will be extraordinarily higher and which will give an ever greater reliability of results.
The purpose of the morphological survey is to select, or not, the subjects with which to constitute the base of mares and stallions of the Siciliano horse, from which the first subjects are beginning to be born in this period, produced by the first subjects already included in the stud book during 2024. These newborns will then be examined to see if the products fall within the breed standard’s morphological model definition.
The breed standard is examined through a linear morphological assessment sheet that defines a series of characteristics for each of the 27 horse breeds recognized by the Ministry of Agriculture.
Today, the Sicilian horse is defined as a local autochthonous population with a marked presence of oriental blood. Although this has been highlighted in the past in a number of subjects, it is still very low. Whether this is confirmed or not at the end of the three-year work will be seen.
The breed standard identifies five points for each breed: area of origin, attitudes, typical characteristics, biometric data, and factors that involve subject exclusion from reproduction.
Sicilian is widespread throughout Sicily with a more marked presence in the provinces of Palermo, Enna, Ragusa and Messina. The attitudes are those of saddle work, Olympic equestrian sports, work equitation and light carriage. It has a light head, straight profile, muscular neck, shoulder with good inclination, rump, withers, back and loins, each with its own definition and reference size. The examination of limbs, joints, gait, foot and temperament follows. The latter comes from a biological basis inherited from the father and the mother. The character, which results from a whole series of responses given by the environment, by the interaction with other animals, the place where he is born and raised and that one would always want balanced and docile but this also and above all comes from what happens to him from birth onwards, to how and if he is imprinted, trained and treated by man (and in this area, we add, the gaps are enormous, at the moment are not used in the selections any scientific methods to certify if the horse is authentically balanced and docile).
The biometric data examined are height, thorax, shank, and shoulder, which, as for height and thorax, may also change over time according to the results obtained during the surveys.
But he specified that if the course of years or decades, an average change of a few centimeters can be observed or If, on the other hand, significant changes are noticed over time: is the second case it will mean that “something is wrong”, and ANAREAI will intervene to protect the conservation of genetic diversity, taking into account that historically breed is not a fixed but dynamic concept, for example, even in the face of market demands that may want minor variations while always maintaining the typical and distinctive characteristics of the breed.
He recalled that the standards of race are approved after careful examination by a special ministerial decree. They are not decided freely and arbitrarily but result from careful ponderations and examinations.
He then explained the important rules decided by the Ministry, starting in 2026, regarding the possible exclusion from reproduction of newly born subjects, if they do not meet the criteria of the breed standard. Not always a subject born of an approved stallion and breeder then maintains the breed characteristics, so all new-born belonging to the 27 Italian breeds, as it was until about 7 years ago before a community law that has been passed, will again be examined by an expert who will go to the farm to take a DNA sample and to verify that the animal has the morphological characteristics established by the breed standard in order, if necessary, to exclude them from future reproduction. This is only to preserve the breed itself.
The reviews carried out so far have given these results: out of 173 subjects, 133 were registered in the family tree and 40 were not because they did not fall into the breed standard. In the reviews held in the days immediately preceding the Troina conference, about 70 subjects were examined, and about 50 were registered. Other events in the various Sicilian provinces are planned between May and June this year.

Role of the breeding station in the conservation of the Sicilian equine heritage.
Prof. Gabriele Marino of UNIME explained with a very technical intervention how important the breeding stations (public and private, which are subject to the same laws and must have the same requirements) are for the conservation of the Sicilian genetic heritage through a plan for the surveillance of infectious diseases. It has entered into the details of a whole series of European and national regulations and laws that have followed each other over time, also creating much confusion, which concern the seven most common infectious diseases, their prevention and verification through different types of vaccinations and specific tests, not taking away from the hypothesis that the number of diseases under attention may increase or decrease over time based on what is found in the field.

Experiences in comparison with the Campania and Sicilian Horse Institutes.
Prof. Agnese Rinaldi and Dr. Conte of the Institute of Equestrian Growth of Campania region in Santa Maria Capua in Vetere, presented with 2 video (excellent) and short reports on their experiences with the breeding stations in their region, particularly at their headquarters, including the specialist use of modern techniques for sperm collection and assisted procreation, including the use of embryo-transfer and in vitro techniques that put their institute at the forefront in Italy. For the Ragusa donkey, a collaboration has already been established between the two regional institutes to use these new reproduction techniques. The local breeds in Compamia region are the Neapolitan, the Persano and the Salernitano, all in intense danger of extinction also for the lack of mares, overcome with these joint techniques of assisted procreation that, for example, they have allowed to obtain from three Salernitano mares as many as 12 foals in a breeding season.
Felicita Sciortino. President of the association AREAS (Association of Sicilian Horses and Donkeys).
She presented her experiences as a breeder of Sanfratellano horses and, in particular, the results obtained with her stallion Imperatore, used in hippo therapy, sports and shows, as well as a breeder in her private breeding station on the farm, where they also take the sperm. She reiterated how the expenses have become almost unaffordable for the Sicilian breeders today. He would have wanted to ask the councilor for agriculture of the Sicilian Region many questions, who could not intervene at the conference, specifically on issues related to supporting livestock farming in Sicily. She has announced the opening of a breeding station in San Mauro Castelverde. She hopes that the institute will take action to improve them elsewhere, also looking at improving the breed of Sanfratellano horses to meet the demands of the market in the sporting sectors, to ensure that the new generations of Sanfratellanos can obtain better selling prices, which today cannot even cover living costs.
Amedeo Cultreri. Oriental thoroughbred breeder and Ministry’s technical committee member on stud books.
He briefly explained the vicissitudes of the PSO stud book until, in 2017, it was reformed by finally providing three different sections: the Oriental Sicilian thoroughbred that includes horses bred in purity and whose stud book dates back to 1875, the Oriental derived at 75%, and the Oriental derived at 50%. He then spoke about the selection of the PSO, starting with the fact that it is the only 100% pure European Arabian horse breed, belonging to the only haplotype U, as explained by Prof. Bordonaro.
Many do not know the difference between an Arab horse and an Oriental one, which can be explained starting from the fact that those we call Arabian horses originally belonged to only five specific bloodlines. Local Bedouins usually bred only one specific bloodline, even in consanguinity. The Westerners, on the other hand, once they started to import from the Arabian Peninsula and neighboring areas and raise these horses themselves, did so by mixing the five original bloodlines and called them generally Arabians. The Oriental thoroughbred, on the other hand, imported by the royal Italian army in 1875 from a particular area of the Middle East (Syria/Lebanon) was specially named Oriental by the King Vittorio Emanuele II° to mark its origin from the orient and has maintained its purity of blood line of original genetic strain. In 1974, the W.A.H.O. wanted to standardize the diction of Arabs bred in the world as that of the Arabian horse, wanting to enter the same genealogical book as Arabia and Orientals, but the Sicilian breeders did not accept this imposed rule by remaining outside of this international institution. After so many years, an extremely positive decision resulted, which made the Oriental remain a pure “Arab” horse and therefore today unique in the world (outside the original countries). For example, he recalled that French Arabian horses have only 32% of Arabian blood.
The main problem today is the competence and training of oriental horse breeders, who alone do not have and cannot acquire the necessary professionalism and competence of excellence to apply in their selections and decide which mating to make based on genetics, morphology, and selection objectives they want to achieve.
Nino Salerno. Sicilian horse breeder.
He told the personal story of himself and his wife as breeders and managers of a center for equestrian sports that uses Sicilian horses. He claimed that the breeder’s role must be respected and no longer underestimated. He asked that they participate in the decision-making processes by confronting the institutions, as happened recently for one measure of the Sicilian breed standard that was immediately changed positively. He reiterated that the participation and motivation of young breeders are essential in the years to come; otherwise, there will soon be a gap.
Conclusions.
There was a debate with the public and some specific technical questions for some speakers until the closure of the works by the President of the Silvo Pastoral Company of the Municipality of Troina, Angelo Impellizzeri, who organized the conference very well. In his brief conclusions, he focused on the problems of farmers who, especially after the last two years of cumbersome drought problems, have been brought to their knees. The company that he is chairing wants to place itself as a link between the scientific world, regional institutions and breeders to give the Sicilian horse a vital role, involving the most significant number of breeders even if they had only one or two subjects, even going to “hunt them one by one in the territory”.
Text and photos by Franco Barbagallo.

Leave a Reply