RECOVERY, CONSERVATION AND DEVELOPMENT OF SICILIAN HORSES AND DONKEYS GENETIC RESOURCES

RECOVERY, CONSERVATION AND DEVELOPMENT OF SICILIAN HORSES AND DONKEYS GENETIC RESOURCES
Il commissario straordinario Ignazio Mannino

On Friday, 14 May, the final results of the three-year project Recovery, Conservation and Development of Sicilian Horses and Donkeys Genetic Resources were presented at the headquarters of the Institute Equine Growth for Sicily in Catania. The Institute Equine Growth for Sicily conducted the project in collaboration with the Regional Department of Agriculture, Rural Development and Fisheries, the Universities of Catania (Department of Agriculture, Food and Environment) and Messina (Department of Veterinary Sciences).
The project’s objectives are the development of a plan for the protection and characterisation of recognised Sicilian horse and donkey breeds: the Sicilian Oriental Thoroughbred, the Sanfratellano, the Siciliano, the donkeys Pantesco (or of Pantelleria), Ragusano, and the Grigio Siciliano (Sicilian Grey), whose recognition as a breed is pending. Within the project, a semen bank was also built to store and distribute the semen of breeding stallions owned by the Institute.
The ultimate aims of the project are to reverse the negative trend seen in recent years regarding the reduction of the genetic heritage of local and endangered breeds, the safeguarding, restoration and improvement of biodiversity in Nature 2000 areas ( which are a network of sites of European community interest (SCI) and special protection areas (SPA) created by the European Union for the protection and conservation of habitats and species, animals and plants, identified as priorities by the Member States of the European Union) and also in areas of agriculture and forestry in Sicily subject to natural protection, in agricultural regions of high natural and landscape value that also meets the requirements of PSR Sicily 2014/2020, regarding the preservation and enhancement of biodiversity and germplasm.
Also, as part of the project, three publications produced by the Institute Equine Growth for Sicily were presented:
– A small volume of extreme scientific and informative interest, which contains the acts of the conference.
– A catalogue that presents and describes a selection of stallions of the various breeds of the Institute, kept in the stables of the Catania headquarters, in the Ambelia estate, and at the two breeding stations of San Fratello and Caronia.
– The restoration of an old register from 1935, found in the archives of the Institute, in which were indicated the presence in those years of the horses and donkeys owned by  the then “Deposito Cavalli Stalloni del Regno di Catania” (Depot of Horse Stallions of the Kingdom in Catania) and their distribution in all the numerous breeding stations scattered throughout Sicily at that time. The register offers valuable insight into the equestrian history of Sicily and a knowledge and cultural heritage that can be preserved and handed over to researchers and Sicilian breeders.
Ketty Torrisi, Veterinarian and official of the Institute, introduced the numerous interventions.

Il Direttore dell’Istituto Michele Bentivegna

The value of animal biodiversity and the importance of research.
In his introductory and welcoming speech, the special commissioner of the Institute, Ignazio Mannino, reiterated the commitment of the Department of Agriculture to carry out the project over time, key to safeguard and especially improve the genetic heritage of Sicilian breeds through the synergies implemented so far between the Institute, universities and breeders. For the sustainability and development of modern agriculture, livestock biodiversity is an essential value for maintaining the socio-economic structure of the various Sicilian horse farms, often located in mountainous and disadvantaged areas at risk of depopulation.

The director of the Institute, Michele Bentivegna, briefly mentioned how the Universities of Catania, especially for the genetic part, and Messina, especially for the morphological part, have conducted extensive genetic sampling and morphological measurements in Sicily over time, essential data search tools that will make it possible to take the right practical decisions in the future to establish the criteria to be adopted about the development of the next generations of Sicilian breeds.
He informed that the current Councillor for Agriculture, Salvatore Barbagallo, has ensured the expansion of the Institute’s scientific laboratory to expand, improve, and complete the study of the data from genetic samples taken during the different phases of the project, which were described below by the specialists who took part. Further data collection will also be carried out in the coming years.

Salvatore Bordonaro, Docente del Dipartimento di Agricoltura, Alimentazione e Ambiente

Presentation of the project.
Salvatore Bordonaro, Professor of the Department of Agriculture, Food and Environment of the University of Catania, presented the project’s structure, starting from the acquisition and study of the many historical documentary sources kept in the Institute’s archives. They include several hippology studies on the Sicilian breeds at that time, the complete documentation on the subjects of Sicilian Oriental Thoroughbreds imported in 1884 from the orient and the crucially essential identification files of each of the individual equine and donkey subjects belonging to the Institute, so useful also about the now close recognition of the breed of the Sicilian Grey donkey.
He illustrated, also using numerous photographs, the many surveys and visits carried out on farms scattered around the island holding animals attributable to the populations of the breeds to be characterised, to carry out the individual biological sampling necessary for the creation of the equine and asinine DNA bank for the collection in the laboratory of molecular information needed for the study of the genomic structure of existing Animal Genetic Resources.
During these three years, the project has been presented for public information purposes at numerous trade fairs, conferences, exhibitions, and events to raise awareness of its importance.
The work concerning the new breed of the Siciliano Horse is significant, carried out in collaboration with A.N.A.E.R.A.I (National Association of Italian Horse Breeders) and A.R.A.C.S. (Regional Association of Siciliano Horse Breeders), with the collection of samples from over 250 subjects and that will continue for the next two years, providing a large amount of data of great importance that will also serve to study the interactions between the three Sicilian breeds and the others imported in Sicily during his history.

Alessandro Zummo, Docente del dipartimento di Scienze Veterinarie

The morphological characterisation.
Alessandro Zummo, Professor of the Department of Veterinary Sciences at the University of Messina, explained the importance of the morphological and genetic characterisation of livestock populations for their conservation and subsequent exploitation based on the data obtained. He then summarised the results of the Morphological Characterisation of Sicilian horses, with specific data about the Sanfratellano horse, the Siciliano, and the Grigio Siciliano donkey.
For the Sanfratellano, the study allowed the evaluation of the evolution of the type morphology influenced by the choices made in the past for breeding stallions and environmental effects. Twenty-two specific measurements were carried out on each of the 96 subjects examined to calculate the most representative biometric indices (lateral, transverse body conformation, thoracic, dactyl-thoracic or bone structure, cephalic, and profile). The results have shown that over time, the average height at the withers has grown by 5 centimetres, probably due to selections tending to have a horse of greater size with crosses made from 1959 to 67 with Hungarian Nonius horses.  Sanfratellano males and females have almost equal values in trunk length, head, shank circumference, and circumference of the shin and thorax.
The index analysis classifies it as a mesodolicomorph horse, compact, solid, with a proportioned head, even if sometimes long and slightly heavy. The study of profiles is interesting: 57.9% have a straight profile today. Only 23.7% have the typical somewhat curved profile, a feature that in the past was much more widespread (18.4% have a mixed profile). The coat has 53.9% dark brown, 26.3% dark bay and 19.7% bay in different shades. The data obtained suggests that, compared to past practices, today’s future selection plan should redesign its attitudes in sports to enhance this breed, which today counts only 1400 heads.

Trionfo Siculo, stallone di Cavallo Siciliano

Since 2008, studies during the search for Siciliano horses have covered around 400 subjects to arrive in February 2024 at the breed recognition. The results highlighted a mesomorphic-mesodolicomorph horse. The average value at the withers is 157.84 cm with a sternum-ground height of 88.49 cm, which testifies to the ability to proceed safely and quickly on any terrain. The indices indicate a very compact, structurally solid horse with excellent resistance and a morphologically proportioned head in most subjects. His skills relate to his use in equestrian tourism, work equitation (where he has excelled for years), dressage, jumping, cross country and the three-day event. Only at the end of the selection campaign, in two years, will the actual number of subjects registered in the breed register be found.
For the ancient breed of the Grigio Siciliano donkey, an innovative approach was used, easy to apply in the field, that focuses attention on a few characters, able to give answers, also at a distance, of undoubted objectivity, in a faster and cheaper way than a complete morphological study. The primary morphological descriptors are 3: size (small, medium, large), coat (type, colour and other characteristics) and iris colour (depigmented, blue, chestnut). The survey was carried out on 73 subjects (63 females). The measurements and indices indicate a propensity to meso-dolicomorphism, comparable to that of the donkey of Pantelleria, which testifies a remarkable resistance to fatigue and to the work of a solid and structurally compact animal, characteristics that, in the past, have allowed to define it as the wealth of the small farmer, the gardener and the fertiliser. The best current uses are for eco-tourism and assisted interventions (pet therapy).

Morena Carlentini, Dottoranda del Dipartimento di Agricoltura, Alimentazione e Ambiente

The genetic diversity of the Sicilian equine heritage.
Morena Carlentini, PhD student at the Department of Agriculture, Food and Environment of the University of Catania, explained how fundamental the study of genetic diversity and consanguinity levels is to develop more effective strategies for maintaining healthy gene groups, preserving unique and indigenous breeds and ensuring the sustainability and resilience of reduced livestock populations such as disease resistance, fertility, adaptation to changing environmental conditions. Over the past 10 years, genomic analysis technology has made great strides in quality and cost, significantly reducing the costs of animal genome scanning for genetic diversity and selective fingerprint studies.
In the middle of the Mediterranean Sea, Sicily has always been a crossroads of continuous flows of animal germplasm that have accompanied the many and different dominations, especially regarding equines, once war animals, work, packing and today sport, affection, tourism, and companionship. The genomic characterisation of the Sicilian Oriental Thoroughbred, Sanfratellano and Siciliano horse breeds is therefore of fundamental importance. In the study within this project, the genetic variability and level of consanguinity of the three Sicilian horse breeds were assessed using a panel of combined markers and compared with molecular data already available in the literature to obtain a picture of the distribution of the three in the global context of diversity. In addition, continuous homozygosity genomic regions were investigated (i.e., areas of the genome where markers with homozygous genotype are continuously sequenced and both alleles – maternal and paternal copies of a gene – are identical) to test the level of hereditary autozygosity. Excessive consanguinity within a population can led to a general decline in genetic health.  Finally, regions of heterozygosity (genetic state in which an organism has two different alleles for a given gene) were analysed for portions of the genome that present a significantly higher level of heterozygosity than the genomic average, usually related to phenomena of balanced selection where diversity is favoured. The analysis identified an area of the genome with greater genetic diversity in chromosome 7, shared by the three Sicilian races, that hosts genes involved in the development and regeneration of muscle tissues, identifying also genetical markers associated with the immune response in all three breeds, traits related to environmental adaptation in Sanfratellano, genes related to the fertility rate in Sanfratellano and Siciliano and sports performance in the Sicilian Oriental Thoroughbred. 234 horses of the three Sicilian breeds were examined. The molecular data were compared with those of 814 subjects of 35 breeds. The multidimensional scale analysis produced, which allows to graphically display a spatial distribution of the analysed samples highlighting the similarity (or dissimilarity) between each pair of individuals, showed a partial overlap between the Siciliano and Sanfratellano breeds within a macro-group of Saddle horses, in which it is possible to distinguish Spanish horses (Andalusian, Lusitano), American races (Quarter horse and Morgan) and other Italian horse breeds (Maremmano), mostly hot-blooded meso-dolicomorphic saddle horses. The Sicilian Oriental Thoroughbred has shown closeness to Arabian horses, as predicted by the news about the origin and history of this breed.
The values of heterozygosity of the three Sicilian breeds were found to be broadly comparable. In the Orientals, there have been migration phenomena, which the introduction of Arab-breed stallions can explain. The consanguinity index grows from the Siciliano to the Sanfratellano and the Oriental. The analysis of genomic structure has confirmed the evolutionary history of the three Sicilian horse breeds, characterised by careful mating plans for the Oriental and Sanfratellano breeds, and the historical hybridisation of Oriental and Anglo-oriental horses in the Siciliano horse, which approximate the genomic structure of this new breed to that of the other Sicilian horses.
The genomic analysis of the three Sicilian horse breeds has confirmed that the Sicilian Oriental Thoroughbred is the breed in which the highest selective pressure was recorded, due to the reduced number of subjects. A different scenario has been detected in the Sanfratellano and Siciliano horses, which have greater consistency and variability.
Continuous monitoring of population genetic diversity is an indispensable tool for studying the dynamics between individuals and races, controlling the consanguinity rate, planning mating properly, preserving those characteristics that the Sicilian horses have developed in relation to the breeding environment, and, therefore, ultimately enhancing the local genetic resources.

Serena Tumino, ricercatrice del Dipartimento di Agricoltura, Alimentazione e Ambiente

The genetic diversity of the Sicilian asinine heritage and the genetic characterisation at the loci associated with the coat’s colour.
Serena Tumino, researcher of the Department of Agriculture, Food and Environment of the University of Catania, presented the likely stages of domestication and spread of the donkey (Equus asinus). According to historical and scientific reconstructions, it all began about 7,000-8,000 years ago in a belt between the Eastern Sahara of Egypt and Sudan and Eritrea; from there the donkeys spread by land to the Arabian Peninsula, Europe and the Mediterranean basin and by sea via Yemen to Central Asia, China and Mongolia. There have been secondary returns from the Middle East and southern Europe to West Africa throughout history. After the collapse of the use of the donkey as a post-mechanisation work and animal, there is now a renewed interest in the donkey breeds for milk production, for eco-tourism and pet therapy.
In Sicily, there are three native donkey breeds: the Pantelleria donkey (or Pantesco), the Ragusano and the Grigio siciliano (or Ferrante). Within the same intervention, the results of mitochondrial DNA analysis to explore genetic variability and evolutionary history by maternal line were presented for 81 individuals of the three Sicilian breeds. Comparing them with a large existing Mediterranean, Balkan, Asian and African database, these data show that Ragusano and Grigio come from a complex phylogenetic history, the result of exchanges, trade routes, and historical interactions with other Mediterranean-African territories that identify them as significant reservoirs of biodiversity. The Pantesco is distinguished by its belonging to a single mitochondrial line, reflecting its past, which was marked by a substantial “bottleneck” due to its development at the point site of the island of Pantelleria. The intervention was concluded by presenting the results and practical implications of the characterisation of genes determining coat colour in donkeys for selective management of breeding animals, carefully choosing the couplings to avoid the spread of unwanted phenotypes, such as the Monachino (all black) phenotype found in some subjects of Pantesco and Ragusano, resulting from the presence in homozygous of the allele that causes it (ASIP gene).

Andrea Criscione, Docente del Dipartimento di Agricoltura, Alimentazione e Ambiente

Andrea Criscione, Professor of the Department of Agriculture, Food and Environment at the University of Catania, presented the results obtained within the ASINITA project, which involved several Italian university centres for the sampling of 220 donkeys from the 8 Italian breeds (Amiata, Asinara, Martina Franca, Romagnolo, Sardo, Viterbese, Pantesco and Ragusano) and the population of the Grigio Siciliano, characterised by SNP markers distributed in 30 chromosomes. Subsequently, he presented the characterisation investigation using microsatellite markers on more subjects of the three genetic types (Pantesco, Ragusano and Grigio Siciliano). Genetic variability, consanguinity, genetic relationships between individuals and populations and potential selective signatures were studied. Varying levels of mixing and genetic isolation were found among the nine Italian donkey populations. Potential selective signatures have been identified in chromosomal regions related to immune response, mastitis resistance, trypanosomiasis resistance and adaptation to changing environmental conditions. For the Sicilian breeds, diversity indices were lower for the Pantesco donkey due to its genetic isolation, and higher for the Ragusano and Grigio Siciliano, which also had a high genetic mix. The Pantesco donkey, despite the small number of existing breeders, has maintained a level of consanguinity that is still under control. Still, conservation strategies are needed to prevent further loss of genetic variability and include an increase in the size of the existing population.

Carla Manenti, Veterinario dell’Istituto

Conservation of local animal genetic resources through mating plans and cryopreservation of semen.
Adequate mating plans, the containment of the level of consanguinity, the maintenance of the morphological and molecular structure characteristic of the different breeds, and the creation of an appropriate semen bank for each breed are essential for preserving animal genetic resources at risk of extinction.
Carla Manenti, veterinarian of the Horse Growth Institute for Sicily, has illustrated the different, complex and delicate phases of the sampling of the seminal material that constitutes the semen bank of the Institute and, therefore, the mating plans of the Horse Growth Institute for Sicily for the equine and asinine species of which it holds and maintains stallions and farmyards at the estate of Ambelia and the headquarters in Catania.  To establish a semen bank, it is necessary to start from the

preparation of the stallions to the use of the mannequin and the artificial vagina for the collection of semen. Then proceed to the qualitative and quantitative evaluation of the semen, dilute it, centrifuge it, and pack it in pajettes that contain a fixed guaranteed share of sperm cells. They are then chilled at 5°, then cryogenically appropriately frozen to be stored in liquid nitrogen at -196° C, so they can then be distributed to breeders who will request semen. The semen of 11 stallions from Orientals, 8 from Sanfratellano, 1 from Siciliano, 4 from Ragusano, and 1 from Grigio Siciliano is preserved.
He then briefly illustrated the mating plans 2024-2025 studied for the Institute’s 14 Ragusano and 29 Oriental mares, each indicated with his name, father and mother names, and the designated stallion chosen for mating in 2024 and 2025.

Trionfo Siculo. Stallone di Cavallo Siciliano

Trionfo Siculo.
In the queue of scientific reports, a beautiful framed black and white giant picture was presented that portrays in Ambelia, with the background of Etna, the last purchase of the Institute: the Siciliano horse stallion Trionfo Siculo, whose semen will soon become part of the Institute’s semen bank. On this occasion, the president of A.R.A.C.S., Francesco Russo, spoke briefly to tell the thirty-year process that in February 2024 led to the coveted recognition of the breed.

 

Text and photos by Franco Barbagallo.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.